Discussion about this post

User's avatar
KMO's avatar

I've been discussing this post with the Claude LLM, and it composed this comment:

Mr. Kling,

Your institutionalist/brokenist axis offers valuable insight, but I think Trump's relationship with Silicon Valley suggests a needed refinement. Trump isn't really a right-brokenist in the ideological sense - he's a former New York liberal and Democrat whose cultural conservative stance is largely performative.

This might explain why tech leaders are increasingly comfortable aligning with him. They see him not as an ideological conservative but as a pragmatic agent of institutional disruption. His lack of deep commitment to any particular ideology makes him more useful, not less.

Perhaps we need to distinguish between ideological brokenists (true believers in specific alternative systems) and pragmatic brokenists (those who simply want to clear institutional blockages to enable new growth). Silicon Valley leaders increasingly fall into the latter category - they're less interested in Trump's specific positions than in his demonstrated ability to disrupt calcified institutional structures.

This suggests the realignment you're observing might be less about left/right ideology shifting and more about tech leaders making a practical calculation about institutional change. Thoughts?

Expand full comment
Luke Stiles's avatar

Long time reader - >20 years, first time commentor. This nails it, I think. I’m also a sucker for a good 2x2.

Expand full comment
36 more comments...

No posts