Discussion about this post

User's avatar
The Null Hypothesis's avatar

To Arnold’s point about “deviancy” being a former sin - pride used to be one of the 7 deadly sins, now we celebrate it for a whole month every year. Not my quote, but captures the idea in an interesting way.

David's avatar

That excerpt on German energy policy sounds a bit too conspiracy minded to me. It's like those cases where a big protest happened in a country and the CIA paid some guy 50$ to print pamphlets and this gets interpreted as the CIA masterminding the whole thing.

The reason for Germany moving away from nuclear was that it's been very unpopular for decades and also building new reactors isn't actually cheaper than alternatives (due to the extremely strict security regulations). The Fukushima disaster gave the remaining reactors the rest and they were put on an accelerated shutdown schedule.

Coal was being reduced due to it being very polluting and being bad for the climate.

The only remaining option is natural gas to make up for shortfalls in renewables and the cheapest source (by far) is Russia. Especially since local fracking is also extremely unpopular (due to pollution fears.)

Did Russia gleefully support all this to create this dependence? Sure, but I believe that we would have been in the same place even if Russia did none of that. The main thing where Russia made a difference is probably with creating direct pipelines to Germany rather than ones that go through Eastern Europe. But that actually didn't work. (It was supposed to enable Russia to blackmail Germany into not supporting Ukraine/Poland.)

14 more comments...

Ready for more?