In My Tribe

Share this post
Genius Stifled, 5/12
arnoldkling.substack.com

Genius Stifled, 5/12

No more miracle years?

Arnold Kling
May 12
Comment5
Share

Dwarkesh Patel writes,

I still don’t think I fully understand why these miracle years keep showing up in the lives of great scientists, except that it has something to do with them being young, concentrating intensely on the right problems, and remaining open to fresh perspectives.

Given how many of the great scientific discoveries have come about during miracle years, we should do everything we can to help smart Twentysomethings have an annus mirabilis. We should free them from rote menial work, prevent them from being overexposed to the current paradigm, and give them the freedom to explore far-fetched ideas without arbitrary deadlines or time-draining obligations.

It’s depressing that I have just described the opposite of a modern PhD program

It is possible that freedom and mentorship promote genius, and that formal education stifles it. That does not mean that formal education is bad for everyone. But it may be sub-optimal for the most talented.

Share

Comment5
ShareShare

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

John Bowman
May 12

‘ We should free them from rote menial work, prevent them from being overexpose…’

Simple solution, stop all Government research grants, then young minds will not be drawn to areas which are fashionable, hot issues for politicians and the activist/lobby industry and where the money is.

How much talent is diverted and engaged in finding ‘green solutions’ for this and that simply to duplicate technology we already have which serves well, and with what added benefit?

For example. What is the benefit to our society and economy from huge amounts of capital and resources going into development (fat chance) of enormous, expensive batteries to store wind/solar generated electricity?

Expand full comment
ReplyGive gift
[redacted]
May 12

Remember the time that Thiel and Blake Masters (best porn name ever?) wrote that book 0 to 1. That was like cool and stuff. Like a call to action for this generation.

Well an update: we have almost reached our moonshot goal. We just need a few more food delivery services and stationary bikes with monthly subscription fees.

My deepest respect for the geniuses out there who brought us this stuff. The spillover effects have been enormous.

Expand full comment
Reply
3 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Arnold Kling
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing