Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Scott Gibb's avatar

But I don’t think an AI mentor will fulfill our desire for mutual respect, or as you say in Three Languages, high self-regard; not even if carefully programmed. What will happen to those unaware of this? Will they become ill seeking respect from an AI?

“As Adam Smith pointed out, we have a desire for high self-regard. In part, we want to be recognized by others as being admirable. Moreover, each of us has what Smith called an ‘impartial spectator,’ or conscience, which makes us feel happier when we believe that we are acting in a way that others will regard highly. Following group norms is a way to please the impartial spectator.” Pg 45, The Three Languages of Politics

Expand full comment
Richard Fulmer's avatar

“I would be happy to use an AI to grade student papers.”

Today’s teachers would have to develop a grading script that is entirely different than yours. Does this essay compellingly relate the author’s sense of victimhood? Does it use the proper opaque woke jargon? Does it reflect the urgent need to tear down the existing system and create a new future that is free of constraints? Does it dismiss all dissent with ringing declarations and emotive slogans that are devoid of substance?

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts